Should you choose a new-build or a doer-upper?
Investing in property has long been a popular method for generating income and building wealth, especially in the UK’s buy-to-let market. However, before considering your options, one crucial decision must be made: should you choose the convenience of a new build or the potential of a fixer-upper?
Each option offers a distinct set of benefits and challenges. The best choice will depend on your individual circumstances, resources, and investment objectives. This article explores both options in detail, providing real-world examples to assist in your decision-making process.
Weighing upfront costs
For many investors, the initial cost of purchasing a property is a significant factor in their decision. New builds often have a higher price tag due to their modern features, adherence to the latest standards, and overall readiness for rental. However, what you gain is a hassle-free investment that typically requires little to no work beyond buying furniture.
On the flip side, doer-uppers tend to be significantly cheaper but require extra funds for renovations. For example, an older two-bedroom property in Birmingham might be bought for £180,000, allowing for an additional £40,000 to be spent on refurbishments while still being under the price of similar move-in-ready properties in the same area. The attraction here is the potential to add immediate value, often benefiting investors in both the short and long term.
Balancing effort and returns
One advantage of new builds is the minimal effort needed to convert them into income-generating assets. With everything brand new and constructed to modern specifications, attracting renters quickly becomes easier. Demand is particularly strong for energy-efficient properties in emerging commuter areas, as tenants are increasingly attracted to lower utility costs and contemporary living spaces.
Doer-uppers, on the other hand, demand a considerable level of commitment. Renovations require time, expertise, and the ability to handle complications that may arise, such as uncovering hidden structural issues. Nonetheless, the rewards can be substantial, both in terms of increased rental yields and capital appreciation. For instance, upgrading an older property by incorporating eco-friendly features like solar panels might attract eco-conscious tenants willing to pay a premium.
Understanding maintenance obligations
If you prefer to keep maintenance issues to a minimum, a newly built property is the way to go. Most new-build homes come with a 10-year builder’s warranty, covering structural issues and defects. Additionally, modern systems such as boilers and electrical installations are much less likely to fail early in their life cycle, helping you avoid unexpected costs.
Older homes, while often full of charm, carry the caveat of increased upkeep. From replacing outdated plumbing to repairing ageing roofing, older properties require a consistent investment in maintenance. However, if managed properly, these challenges can be outweighed by the financial benefits of owning a beautifully restored property in a high-demand area.
Location matters more than you think
The location of your buy-to-let property can significantly impact its long-term profitability. New builds are often situated in purpose-built communities within growing suburban areas. These areas are designed to attract families and professionals seeking a blend of convenience, green spaces, and local infrastructure.
Doer-uppers are often located in more established neighbourhoods, which can offer unique advantages. Investing in a traditional terraced house in an up-and-coming London suburb, for instance, could lead to a sharp increase in value as the area becomes more desirable. Additionally, renters are frequently drawn to the character and history that these homes provide.
Consider tax incentives and environmental impact
The UK government continues to encourage landlords to prioritise energy efficiency. New-build properties generally have excellent EPC ratings, which can lead to lower utility bills for tenants while enabling landlords to easily comply with legal requirements for rental properties.
Meanwhile, investing in an older home and making significant energy-efficiency upgrades can qualify you for certain tax incentives or government grants. If you’re willing to put in the effort, these renovations can be a double win, enhancing your property’s energy efficiency while also increasing its market value.
Matching investments to your goals
The choice between a new build and a fixer-upper largely depends on your investment strategy, timeline, and resources. For those with limited time or experience, a new build can offer an easier way to enter the market. With modern amenities and a ready-to-rent condition, it’s possible to start generating income almost immediately.
Conversely, seasoned investors or those with a network of dependable contractors may find fixer-uppers to be the ideal way to maximise returns. Adding value through renovation can greatly enhance both rental income and capital appreciation, although this path necessitates patience and planning.
Case study 1
Consider Lucy, a first-time investor in Edinburgh. She bought a new-build flat for £230,000 in a vibrant new development known for its strong eco-credentials. Within weeks, she secured a tenant paying £1,100 monthly, with minimal effort required.
Case study 2
Contrast this with James, an experienced property developer from Leeds. He acquired a mid-terrace Victorian property for £150,000, investing £50,000 to restore its original features while modernising its interior. Today, the property is valued at £280,000 and rents for £1,400 per month. Both strategies were effective, yet they appealed to different types of investors.
Are you considering a buy-to-let mortgage for your upcoming investment property?
Whether you see the appeal of a modern, turnkey property or relish the challenge of bringing a doer-upper back to life, the key is finding the right funding option for you. If you’d like tailored advice or further information to help make your decision,speak to Fitch & Fitch – telephone 020 7859 4098 – email info@fitchandfitch.co.uk.